It is the general concensus that Macs are more expensive than PCs. Naturally, most of us believe this without thinking about; why would we bother to question such an accusation? 95% of us use Windows anyways; it's not worth our time to delve into such research. I, however, found that it was worth my time. The research that I did was simply into the comparison of the most modern Apple notebook and the most modern Dell notebook; I will not compare a Mac to a discounted wholesale notebook.
It turns out that depending on how you value certain hardware components and software applications, you may find that a Mac can be a better deal than a Dell. To prove such a statement, I spent too much time creating the table below, which compares two very similar notebooks: an Apple MacBook and a Dell Inspiron. I should note that I calculated the final prices by customizing each notebook at its respective company's online Canadian store.
|
VS |
|
Apple MacBook |
Model |
Dell Inspiron 640m |
Mac OS 10.4 (Tiger) |
OS |
Windows XP Home (SP2) |
2.0GHz Intel Core Duo |
Processor |
2.0GHz Intel Core Duo |
1GB 667mhz DDR2 SDRAM |
Memory |
1GB 667mhz DDR2 SDRAM |
80GB SATA |
Hard Disk |
80GB SATA |
64MB Intel Integrated |
Video Card |
64MB Intel Integrated |
13.3" Glossy [1280 x 800] |
Screen |
14.1" Glossy [1440 x 900] |
DVD±RW/CD-RW [SLOT] |
Disc Drive |
DVD±RW/CD-RW [TRAY] |
Wi-Fi (802.11g) |
Wireless |
Wi-Fi (802.11g) |
1 Year |
Warranty |
1 Year |
iLife 2006 Front Row |
Software |
WordPerfect
|
Integrated iSight Bluetooth 2.0+EDR 1 Firewire 400 Ports 2 USB 2.0 Ports Mini-DVI Port Built-in Mic Apple Remote |
Other |
Exterior Media Controls RJ11 Modem port S-Video 4 USB 2.0 Ports Monitor Port 5-in-1 Card Reader |
$1,629
|
Price |
$1,779
|
So it looks like, if you can pass up on a modem, a few USB ports, and a few hundred pixels of scren size, you will get a (somewhat) cheaper machine that not only has so much more included (and useful) software, but is also hugely attractive. I could have upped the Dell's price and included Windows Media Center edition and a 40-button remote, but that would make the Dell seem too much more more expensive. And the point of this article is not to reach a conclusion that Macs are cheaper than PCs, because they aren't.
The question is really about which is a better deal. Price does play a big part, but so does the OS, the software, the specs, and the special hardware features. How can you even compare the value of Windows and Mac OS X. While OS X is much, much cheaper than Windows XP (and do you compare it to Professional or Media Center Edition?) it could be argued that Windows is more feature-rich. Also, how much do you value a virus-free world, not having to purchase Norton or McFae? There's really no way to honestly state which is a better deal. If you knew me, you'd know I would argue ('till I die) that the MacBook is a better deal, but my values obviously differ from yours.
The point of this post is not to declare a winner, but rather, to point out that the cultural consensus that PCs are a much better deal than Macs is not the case.